
- Buchholz won a rainy FHSAA Class 5A-Region 1 semifinal 32-31 against Nease after coming from behind late in the game.
- Junior quarterback Andrew Whittemore ran over 150 yards and led key drives, including a final drive tying the game before the winning extra point.
- Buchholz improves to 11-1 and will face top seed Mandarin in the regional final Thanksgiving weekend.
The Buchholz football program has earned the moniker “Cardiac Cats” over the last several years, while “gritty, not pretty” has become the team’s mantra.
On a rainy and windy Friday night at Citizens Field, also known as “The Pit,” the No. 2 seed Bobcats were both in a come-from-behind 32-31 win against No. 3 seed Nease (Ponte Vedra) in a FHSAA Class 5A-Region 1 Semifinal.
“Well, just a tremendous effort on the part of our kids,” said Buchholz coach Mark Whittemore. “I don’t know if this is a good tradition or not that we’ve built winning like this, but a win is a win and it’s a lot of fun, but it kind of takes some hairs off your head.”
They never gave up and that’s why the Bobcats (11-1) will get another practice on a Thanksgiving holiday in preparation for a trip to top seed Mandarin (Jacksonville) for the region final.

“I mean that’s kind of what we preach throughout, from spring to right now,” said Buchholz junior quarterback Andrew Whittemore, who ran for over 150 yards to give him over 1,000 for the season. “We’re gonna play as hard as we can every play, and we’re not gonna look at the scoreboard until the clock hits zero, and I think that’s what we did tonight.”
Buchholz trailed the entire game, but down six with less than five minutes to play, the ‘Cats put together one final drive to keep their season alive.
Following a Nease (8-4) punt that was returned 31 yards by junior Avery Norris, the Bobcats took over at the Panthers’ 49-yard line with 4:29 remaining.
A 14-yard pass from quarterback Andrew Whittemore to FAU commit Dominick Harvey (5 catches for 135 yards), followed by a 15-yard personal foul on Nease for grabbing Harvey’s facemask, put the ball at the 20-yard line.

Whittemore ran for five yards on the next play, followed by an aggressive 15-yard scoring run on the next play to tie the game at 31-all. Senior kicker Timothy Ortiz’s extra point gave the Bobcats a 32-31 lead, their first of the game, with 2:44 to play.
A Buchholz pass interference on a fourth-and-10 put Nease at the Bobcats’ 42-yard line, but a diving interception by senior Isaiah Robinson a few plays later put the game on ice.
It was one of only two combined turnovers the entire night.
“To only have two turnovers in this weather, come on, it’s unbelievable,” Mark Whittemore said. “It was really, really good football. Frankly, you had two really good quarterbacks. You had some excellent ball players out there that really wanted to win it for their team, and we were able to come through in the end.”
Both teams made big plays, but the Bobcats spent most of the night playing catch-up.

They trailed 14-0 before Whittemore led the ‘Cats on a 10-play, 80-yard drive for their first score of the night. He capped the drive with a 2-yard run, but the snap was bobbled on the extra point with 1:27 left in the half and Nease led 14-6 at the half.
On the first play from scrimmage in the second half, Buchholz junior running back Josh Menefee scored on an 80-yard touchdown run. However, Whittemore was stopped on the 2-point conversion run as Buchholz and the ‘Cats trailed 14-12, just 12 seconds into the second half.
A 27-yard field goal by Aric Davis-Baer extended the lead to five, 17-12, with 9:19 remaining in the third quarter.
Whittemore then fumbled on Buchholz’s next possession and Nease’s Austin Taylor recovered at the Bobcats’ 28-yard line. A couple of plays later, senior Tyshawn Ford scored on a 38-yard run for a 24-12 lead with 8:32 to play in the third quarter.
Buchholz answered with a 9-play, 80-yard drive as Whittemore dove over the top on a fourth-and-goal at the 1-yard line. Ortiz added the extra point to get the Bobcats within five, 24-19, with 3:54 to play in the third quarter.
Whittemore had a 24-yard run on the drive and a 25-yard pass to Harvey, who would eventually eclipse 1,000 yards receiving.
But Ford added a 35-yard touchdown run just 90 seconds later to put the Panthers up 12 again, 31-19.
High School Football
Area teams in bold
Thursday, Nov. 19
FHSAA FIT 3A-1A
Suwannee (Live Oak) 1, Cypress Lake (Fort Myers) 0 (forfeit)
Eastside 38, FAMU (Tallahassee) 0
Friday, Nov. 20
Sunshine State Athletic Association (SSAA) 8-man championship game:Sports Leadership & Management (SLAM) (Tampa) 34, Saint Francis Catholic Academy 12
FHSAA playoffs – Regional Semifinals
Class 1A-Region 1
Blountstown 30, Fort White 10
Class 1A-Region 2
University Christian (Jacksonville) 20, Hawthorne 0
Class 4A-Region 1
Choctawhatchee (Fort Walton Beach) 32, Columbia (Lake City) 7
Class 5A-Region 1
Buchholz 32, Nease (Ponte Vedra) 31
Saturday, Nov. 21
Class 3A-Region 2
Santa Fe (Alachua) at Merritt Island, 7:30 p.m.

One of the big plays of the night was a bad snap over the head of Buchholz senior punter Radley Ruland, who ran back to the goal line to retrieve it and somehow got a good punt off, giving Nease the ball at the Buchholz 47-yard line.
Nease was forced to punt and Buchholz junior Caden Dowdell blocked the punt to give the ‘Cats a first down at the Nease 37-yard line.
Those two plays seemed to open the door to a comeback as Whittemore completed a 34-yard pass to Harvey, followed by a 3-yard touchdown run by Whittemore with 6:42 remaining. Despite the extra point being blocked, Buchholz was only down 31-25, setting up their improbable victory.
Buchholz, which has been to five straight state semifinals, will have to be road warriors against the Mustangs (11-1), who cruised past Evans (Orlando), 45-6, in their regional semifinal.
“It’s going to be a dogfight,” Mark Whittemore said.
The Bobcats have rallied all season. They overcame a 14-point halftime deficit to win at 6A region finalist Lake Mary in the preseason, beat 4A region finalist Vanguard in Ocala in the season opener, and came back from a 17-3 halftime deficit to win at 4A region finalist Jesuit (Tampa).
“The culture of winning is pretty noticeable at this point, and so I’m really, really pleased with the coaching staff, the program in general, and just these kids this year in 2026, just taking it to another level of tenacity, stick-to-itness, and just thoroughness and preparation as well mentally. I mean, that’s a mental grind.”





